My9s
Creative Commons License
This exhibit has not been peer reviewed.  [Return to Group]  [Printer-friendly Page] 

Victorian Anxiety Over Female Textuality

lbales0423

A Short History of Anti-Masturbation Texts Leading Up to the Victorian Era

Masturbation was not seen as a major social concern until around 1710 when "the quasi-medical text Onania; or, the Heinous Sin of Self-Pollution was published in London; we can infer its considerable influence from the fact that it was into its 20th edition by 1760," (Hunt 575).  From this point forward, masturbation became a topic of public discourse, and more pamphlets began to be published, primarily aimed at helping prevent the vice from taking root, but also towards eradicating it when it had become habitual. The anti-masturbation movement was primarily aimed at middle and upper class men, and most of the earlier texts were focused on the epidemic of male masturbation and the ills that it could cause both morally and physically, with only a few comments made on female masturbators. Female masturbation became a point of contention during the purity movement in the mid to late 19th century. 

Picture
ONANIA defines masturbation as an “unnatural Practice, by which Persons of either Sex, may defile their own Bodies, without the assistance of others, whilst yielding to filthy Imaginations, they endeavor to imitate and procure themselves that Sensation, which God has order’d to attend the carnal Commerce of the two Sexes, for the continuance of our Species” (4). Onania focuses primarily on the problems and solutions to male masturbation, but many of them became applicable to the concerns over female masturbation in the Victorian era. Not only was Onania influential to the reading public, but "historians usually agree that the pivotal event in the secularization of masturbation was the anonymous Onania...It is this book, we are told, that is responsible for the transformation of the sinful practice into a medical and secular issue," (Singy 345). Onania effectively changed masturbation from a private practice into a public discourse. 
The consequences of masturbation are dire and listed clearly in Onania:
  • Hinders the growth both in boys and girls (5). 
  • Can bring ulcers and worse symptoms (5). 
  • "Gonorrhea, more difficult to be cur'd than those contracted from women actually labouring under foul diseases," (5). 
  • Fainting fits, epilepsy, and consumption (6). 
  • "Nightly and excessive Seminal Emissions," (6). 
  • "Loss of erection, as if they had been castrated" (6). 
  • "Barren, as Land becomes poor by being over-till'd; and few...boast of the Fruits of their Marriage Bed," (6). 
  • "If by Nature's extraordinary Help, they should get any Children, which happens not often, they are commonly weakly little ones, that either die soon, or become tender sickly People," (6). 



After listing the physical and moral impact of masturbation, the pamphlet gives helpful advice to those who are afflicted with the "solitary vice": 
  • "YOU must use a spare Diet, but not totally abstain," (8). 
  • Try not to eat much meat and "salted meat you must forbear, which you may know by the nature of the word makes men salacious," (8). 
  • "Eat dry Suppers, unless it be Water-Gruel," (8). 
  • Get married... soon (9). 
Richard C. Sha, in the article Medicalizing the Romantic Libido: Sexual Pleasure, Luxury, and the Public Sphere, says "The explosion of anti-masturbation literature in the eighteenth century peaks around 1750 and helped to make clear that there was no such thing as a purely private pleasure. Insofar as private pleasure had enormous and profound effects on social body--it made, these authors insistently argued, men effeminate, incapable of erection, and women nymphomaniacs, and, what was even worse, women 'indifferent' to the lawful pleasures of Hymen," (34). Masturbation became a portal by which all the ills in society could be dealt with, from class issues, to health issues, to sexuality. In the 19th century, industry rose, and many people moved from the country into the cities, which is reflected in the pamphlets. Many of the techniques to "cure" or "prevent" masturbation was linked with the air, which was considered polluted and filled with sickness in the cities, and suggested that children be brought up away from the cities, where they could have a more wholesome environment. There is also a link made between "onanism" and "sexual and economic productivity, one which helped to make productive sexual pleasure a public virtue," (Sha 36). Masturbation is an unproductive loss of fluids, particularly semen, because instead of heterosexual intercourse, which could result in a child and the propagation of the species, it was an act that only brought solitary pleasure. Marriage was often purported as the ultimate solution because it was both a "prevention and cure for the solitary vice and thus [sought] to convert unproductive pleasure into productive pleasure." (Sha 35). Often insanity and masturbation were linked. This link was made because many people in asylums masturbated without inhibitions, and so it was attributed as the cause of their insanity. 
It was during the Victorian era that the tone changed from an emphasis on male masturbation, to an emphasis on female. Unlike male masturbation, female masturbation was seen much more as a societal issue than a solitary vice. One of the main culprits of this vice in women was attributed to the reading material that women had available to them, and thus the female reader became fetishized. The Reader by Jean-Honore Fragonard was painted in 1772 and is in stark contrast to later depictions of the female reader, possibly because literature was blamed for the influx of alleged indecency in women. Male masturbation was seen as a lack of self-control, which reflected back on the individual, while female masturbation was seen as more problematic on a societal level. One of the purity movements spokespersons in the Victorian era, Priscilla Barker, blamed "'impure literature'... 'Self-abuse is related to a whole set of sinful corruptions, impurity of thought and imagination leading the way into bestial realms of impure literature, art, and the whole science of sin,'" (Hunt 592). During the Victorian era, possibly because of the more readily accessible reading materials and the availability of more “sensational” fiction, reading began to intertwine with female sexuality.
Picture
This is what the Victorians wanted their female readers to look like.